see also:
feature | MacPac Polaris | Marmot Fortress | OnePlanet Wurley 3 | Exped Orion III |
---|---|---|---|---|
price on sale | $AU459 | $AU499 | $AU649 | $AU1299 |
season usage | 3-4 season | 3-4 season | 3-4 season | 4 season and still good in summer although consider Extreme version with silnylon UV fly |
best for.. | 3 school kids or or 1 adult 2 young kids hiking; 2 adults hiking; car camping; | 2 adults or 1 adult 2 young kids hiking; car camping; | kid tough 3 school kids hiking | tall people; 2 adults hiking; unprotected sites eg. Iceland, alpine base camps; high rain/wind cool-cold climate areas; car camping for those with bad backs |
weight | 3.5kg | 2.89kg | 3.5kg | 3.8kg |
storm / wind proofing | good | OK | OK | very good |
livability in prolonged rain 1-2P | OK | OK | OK | excellent |
set up in rain without inner wet | no | yes? | yes? | yes |
ingress/egress | OK | ?OK | smallish doors | excellent |
pole attachment | 2 threaded, ridge clipped | all clipped, will bend a lot in high winds | clipped | all threaded |
poles | 8.5mm T6 | ? | 9.1 and 9.7mm T6 | |
colours | blue with white inner | orange with grey inner | blue with yellow inner | red or green with yellow inner |
inner tent | 40D | 40D | ? | 30D |
floor | 70D 10,000mm | 68D 2000mm | 210D, 5000mm | 70D 10,000mm |
fly | silnylon | 68D 1500mm | 75D polyester | 40D PU |
inner height | 120cm | 117cm | 106cm | 130cm |
internal width | 180cm | 165cm | 195cm | 160cm |
internal length | 217cm | 219cm | 225cm | 220cm |
internal area | 3.6sqm | 3.8 sq.m | 3.5sq.m | |
vestibule width | 75cm | 85-90cm | 95cm | |
vestibule area | 1.6sq.m | 1.8sq.m | 2.5sq.m | |
dual layer door | full, rolls up to non-wind end | 2nd door has less mesh (fixed nylon bottom) and the vestibule door is smaller and hard to get in/out | ?full rolls up to centre of tent | full, rolls up to centre of tent |
ridge pole | to ground | only across top | only across top | to ground |
ability to open wind end vestibule | yes, unclip from pole | yes | yes? | no, unless remove ridge pole and use guy ropes |
door position | triangular starts at non-wind end | central D doors | central small triangular | central D doors |
door rain protection with fly open | OK only | seems OK | seems good | good |
fully nylon sealed inner dust proof mode | yes | no, lower mesh vent can't be closed | yes | yes |
zippable open inner vents | only doors | doors and ceiling vent but no mesh on this | only doors | only doors |
can set up without fly | yes | yes | yes | yes but more difficult and need guy ropes |
can set up with fly only | no | ?no | ?no | yes, easy |